The Best Sweeteners For People With Diabetes
I am often asked about what the best sweeteners are for people with diabetes and what can be used as a replacement for sugar that wont raise blood sugar. Thats why I have created this in-depth guide to natural and artificial sweeteners for people with diabetes.
I get a little frustrated when reading or hearing outright incorrect claims and marketing spin about how some of the natural and artificial sweeteners affect your blood sugar.
As a person with diabetes, I want to know exactly what will happen to my blood sugar when I eat or drink something, and I dont take kindly to half-true marketing claims.
Ive decided to focus on which natural and artificial sweeteners are good for people with diabetes as it relates to impact on blood sugar, rather than on whether they are healthy choices in general since I think that is somewhat out of my domain and because plenty of others have already covered that.
Plasma Glucose And Hormonal Responses To A Glucose Load Were Altered By Sucralose
Mean peak plasma glucose concentration was higher and the subsequent nadir was lower after sucralose than after water ingestion . Peak plasma insulin and C-peptide concentrations were also higher after sucralose than after water ingestion . No significant differences in the incremental AUC of glucose or C-peptide were detected in response to the glucose load after sucralose and water ingestion. However, the incremental AUC of insulin was 20 ± 8% greater after sucralose than after water ingestion . Plasma glucagon concentration and the decremental glucagon AUC after the glucose load were similar after sucralose and water ingestion . Although average plasma GIP concentrations tended to be higher after sucralose than after water ingestion , the difference was not statistically significant . Plasma active GLP-1 concentration, incremental GLP-1 AUC, and incremental GIP AUC after the glucose load were not different after sucralose or water ingestion .
Artificial Sweeteners And Type 1 Diabetes
Foods and drinks that use artificial sweeteners give you more choices when eating or drinking something sweet.
The artificial sweeteners listed have been tested and approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration as generally regarded as safe . GRAS means experts have agreed that it is safe for use in moderation.
Many foods with artificial sweeteners may still have carbohydrate. Always check the label.
Also Check: How To Counter Low Blood Sugar
Allulose A New Artificial Sweetener Thats No Longer Considered An Added Sugar
Allulose is an extremely low-calorie sweetener that occurs naturally in small amounts in wheat, raisins, dried figs, brown sugar, and molasses, according to the FDA. Marketed under the brand name Dolcia Prima , it has 90 percent fewer calories than sucrose, while being 70 percent as sweet.
You can find Dolcia Prima in Magic Spoon Cereal, which is sold online and expect to see it soon in beverages, desserts, candy, yogurt, and other treats. Thats because allulose got a big boost from the FDA in April 2019, when the agency declared it can be excluded from the total and added sugars listed on nutrition labels going forward.
The latest data suggests that allulose is different from other sugars in that it is not metabolized by the human body in the same way as table sugar, says Susan Mayne, PhD, director of FDAs Center for Food Safety and Applied Nutrition. It has fewer calories, produces only negligible increases in blood glucose or insulin levels, and does not promote dental decay.
Under the revised guidance, manufacturers can use a caloric value of 0.4 calories per gram to calculate the total number of calories per serving of allulose, instead of the previous 4 calories per gram. The sweetener still must be included in the total carbohydrates listed, though. While allulose isnt on the list of FDA-approved sweeteners, the agency hasnt questioned notices submitted by manufacturers that the sweetener is generally recognized as safe.
Eating Splenda Every Day Might Increase Your Appetite
You might be tempted to think that eating Splenda every day will have no impact on your appetite. If there are no calories in it, why would it, right? Actually, it’s a bit more complicated than that, according to registered dietitian Kelsey Lorencz. “You’re eating a certain volume of food without the calories and nutrients that should be coming with it,” she told The List. And that can make you super hungry later in the day, which can in turn render you susceptible to overeating.
To that end, you’ll want to pay attention to the way you feel throughout the day when you eat Splenda and make any necessary changes, advised Lorencz. “If you find that you’re extra hungry at night or can’t stay out of the snack pantry once you get home, look at switching some artificially sweetened drinks and foods for an option that includes a balanced combination of carbohydrates, protein, and fat,” she continued. As always, it comes down to listening to your body and making healthy choices.
You May Like: What Is Good Blood Sugar
Is Sucralose Safe For Children
Foodssweetened with sucralose can add sweetness to the diets of children withoutcontributing to increased calorie intake or risk of cavities.
However,due to limited studies in children, the American Academy of Pediatrics hasntprovided official recommendations on low-calorie sweetener intakes for children.
Artificial Sweeteners And Diabetes: Are There Healthy Sugar Substitutes For Diabetics
The topic of artificial sweeteners for diabetes is a confusing one. On one hand, artificial sweeteners are often recommended for people with diabetes because they either contain very little or no sugar, carbs, or calories. Many people use them as sugar substitutes in an effort to be healthier and manage their blood sugar levels.
On the other hand, some artificial sweeteners are not always the best optionsand may actually raise blood sugar with long-term use. Knowing how to recognize the best artificial sweeteners is key. There are low-calorie natural sweeteners that may be more beneficial to your health.
Some examples of more natural sweeteners include:
- Date sugar
- Yacon syrup
Some of these natural sweeteners still contribute to your added sugar intake, so it may be helpful to learn how to detox from sugar. Lowering your intake of sugar and sweeteners overall might be the best call when it comes to managing your blood sugar.
Don’t Miss: What Happens When Blood Sugar Is Too Low
What About Sugar Alcohols
Sugar alcohols are naturally found in plants and berries. The types most often used in the food industry are synthetically created. You can find them in food products that are labeled as sugar-free or no sugar added.
Labels such as this are misleading because sugar alcohols are still carbohydrates. They can still raise your blood sugar, but not as much as regular sugar.
Common FDA-approved sugar alcohols are:
New Evidence Finds Sucralose Does Affect Blood Sugar And Insulin
The artificial sweetener called Splenda is marketed as a “delicious alternative to sugar.” The main ingredient is sucralose, with glucose and maltodextrin as fillers. Sucralose could affect blood sugar and insulin levels, a new study published in Diabetes Care finds. Researchers at Washington University School of Medicine in St. Louis analyzed the effects of sucralose in 17 obese people who don’t have diabetes and dont regularly use artificial sweeteners. The participants consisted of people with an average body mass index of just over 42. A person with a BMI of 30 or higher is considered obese.
The 17 participants were either given water or sucralose to drink before taking a glucose challenge test. The researchers wanted to find out how the combination of sucralose and glucose would affect blood sugar and insulin levels. They tested every participant twice. Participants who drank water followed by glucose in one visit were given sucralose followed by glucose in the next, so that every subject served as their own control group. The researchers found that when participants drank sucralose, their blood sugar levels were at a higher level than when they drank only water before eating glucose. The insulin levels of those who drank sucralose increased by about 20 percent.
You May Like: What Are Good And Bad Blood Sugar Levels
Sucralose And Weight Gain
Lots of people reach for diet soda and calorie-free sweeteners to keep their weight in check. But the jury is still out on whether artificial sweeteners actually help you keep off the pounds.
Some studies have found no link between body weight and low-calorie sweeteners. Others have found that people who replace sugar with low-calorie sweeteners weigh ever-so-slightly less, on average a difference, the researchers found, of fewer than two pounds.
On the other hand, some research suggests that people who drink diet soda might end up eating more calories in food than people who drink sugar-sweetened soda. In other words, sucralose isnt a slam dunk when it comes to weight loss.
A Quick Explainer On Insulin Resistance
Letâs start with the basics: what causes insulin resistance, and why itâs a problem. When we consume sugar, our body produces insulin, which is needed to break down sugars like glucose and sucrose. Cells have insulin receptors on them, which ensure our cells get the right amount of sugars they need.
The problem is that if we continually consume high amounts of sugar, we get repeated high insulin spikes. Over time, the insulin spikes cause our insulin receptors to get worn out and not function well. When this happens, our cells arenât able to absorb the sugars they need, and we end up with too much sugar in our blood. This leads to a host of problems throughout the body.
How Does Eating Splenda Every Day Impact Your Diabetes Risk
Unfortunately for Splenda fans, eating the no-calorie sweetener on a daily basis may just increase the likelihood that you’ll develop type II diabetes.”Your blood glucose/risk of diabetes will increase because Splenda and other alternative sweeteners change the composition of the gut flora,” registered dietitian Trista Best told The List. “This has many health implications, but one interesting effect is its impact on blood glucose regulation.” That was also the conclusion of a study published by the American Diabetes Association. We’re sorry, #TeamSplenda.
However, it’s important to note that the science isn’t entirely clear here, according to Holly Strawbridge, the former editor of Harvard Health. “The American Heart Association and American Diabetes Association have given a cautious nod to the use of artificial sweeteners in place of sugar to combat obesity, metabolic syndrome, and diabetes,” she wrote in an article for Harvard University. That’s because eating sugar is a surefire way to raise your diabetes risk.
It’s complicated and more research is needed to determine just how eating Splenda is connected to diabetes. As always, talk to your doctor or dietitian to find out what’s best for you personally.
Your Body May Adjust To Splenda If You Eat It Every Day
One of the really quirky things about Splenda is that if you eat it every day, your body may eventually adjust to it. For example, consider your blood sugar levels: One small study of folks with severe obesity found that consuming Splenda elevated both their blood sugar and insulin levels. However, these individuals didn’t already have a daily Splenda habit, which is key.
Evidence points to the body adjusting to regular Splenda consumption, according to nutrition writer Hrefna Palsdottir. “Several other studies in people with average weight who didn’t have any significant medical conditions have found no effects on blood sugar and insulin levels,” she penned in an article in Healthline. And these people were definitely regular consumers of Splenda.
If you already eat Splenda every day in small amounts, you probably don’t need to worry about that potentially negative health impact. As Healthine explained, “If you like the taste of sucralose and your body handles it well, it’s probably fine to use in moderation.”
You May Like: Is There Sugar Free Orange Juice
Ask The Doctor: Do Artificial Sweeteners Cause Insulin Resistance
Ask the doctor Q. I’ve heard that artificial sweeteners increase the risk of developing insulin resistance. Is that true? Are some types worse than others? A. You’ve asked a question scientists are still working to answer. Studies of artificial sweeteners are mixed, with some indicating that people using them eat fewer calories and lose weight or maintain a stable weight. However, in a few studies, artificial sweeteners were associated with weight gain, which might increase the risk of developing insulin resistancea condition in which body cells do not respond properly to insulin and thus cannot easily absorb glucose from the blood-stream. Subscribe to Harvard Health Online for immediate access to health news and information from Harvard Medical School.Continue reading > >
Different Types Of Splenda
Splenda offers a whole lot more than their little yellow packets. You can find Splenda products for all your cooking, baking, and mixing needs. Note that some of these products contain ingredients other than sucralose, sometimes including sugar or other sweeteners with calories.
There are also a variety of products that are suitable for keto and plant-based diets. Splenda does not test its products for gluten, but Splenda sweeteners are not made with ingredients that contain gluten, so they should not have it.
Some of the most popular Splenda products include:
Read Also: Is The Sugar In Fruit Bad For Diabetics
Can Pregnant And Breastfeeding Women Consume Sucralose
YES. The consumption of low-calorie sweeteners within their respective ADIs is safe for women who are pregnant or breastfeeding according to the EFSA, FDA and JECFA. Research has shown that sucralose has no adverse effects on expecting or nursing mothers or on the fetus, and there are no known side effects of sucralose consumption.²,¹ Because only small amounts of sucralose are absorbed into the bloodstream, the amount of sucralose present in breast milk is very low.¹ All women who are pregnant or nursing need the necessary nutrients and calories for their babys optimal growth and development, while taking care not to exceed their needs.
Is Sucralose Safe
So whats the verdict on sucralose? Its complicated.
Its true that research has raised some concerns. Yet scientists havent found any direct negative health effects in people who consume sucralose long-term. Thats true both for healthy people and those with diabetes.
While sucralose may cause problems at higher doses, most people consume nowhere near that amount, says Patton. If you enjoy sucralose occasionally and in moderation, it isnt likely to have a major effect on your health.
You May Like: What Is It When You Have Low Blood Sugar
What Is An Adi
The acceptable daily intake, or ADI, is the average daily intake over a lifetime that is expected to be safe based on significant research. It is derived by determining the no-observed-adverse-effect-level, or NOAEL, which is the highest intake level found to have no adverse effects in lifetime studies in animal models, divided by 100.¹ Setting the ADI 100 times lower than the upper level found to have no adverse effects in toxicology studies adds a margin of safety that helps to ensure that human intakes will be safe.
How Artificial Sweeteners Affect Blood Sugar And Insulin
Sugar is a hot topic in nutrition.
Cutting back can improve your health and help you lose weight.
Replacing sugar with artificial sweeteners is one way to do that.
However, some people claim that artificial sweeteners arent as metabolically inert as previously thought.
For example, its been claimed that they can raise blood sugar and insulin levels.
This article takes a look at the science behind these claims.
Also Check: Is Organic Cane Sugar Healthy
Natural And Artificial Sweeteners
It can be confusing to group together sweeteners as the terminologies are open to interpretation. For instance, some products from the stevia plant are marketed as natural, even though theyre processed and refined. Yet, some of the other products marketed as artificial sweeteners may be derived from naturally occurring substances. For example, sucralose, which is used in Splenda, is derived from sugar . Whatever the name, grouping or terminology, its important to ask what is in the particular sweetener and whether the sweetener or product has carbohydrate or calories, and how that fits into your individual goals for healthy eating.
Can Splenda Help With Weight Loss
Many studies suggest that people who use low-calorie sweeteners are able to lose weight more easily, maintain a healthier weight, and control their blood sugar levels better.
For example, one trial found that people who drank beverages sweetened with sucralose lost more weight than people whose beverages contained sugar or another artificial sweetener.
Another analysis of more than 20 studies published in 2014 found that low-calorie sweeteners helped people lose weight and fat mass. They were also able to trim their waists down.
Don’t Miss: What Helps Lower Blood Sugar Naturally
Will You Lose Weight If You Eat Splenda Every Day
One of the main reasons people reach for artificial sweeteners as opposed to good old sugar is because sugar can cause gain weight, as noted by Medical News Today. But is Splenda really a good option if you’re trying to shed unwanted pounds? “Eating Splenda daily may be helpful for those with a goal of weight loss as it is a no-calorie sugar substitute,” registered dietitian Elle Merrill explained to The List. “Sweet tea or coffee can be enjoyed without the additional of unnecessary calories from real sugar.” The same goes for your morning oatmeal or smoothie as well.
But that doesn’t mean that Splenda is a magic bullet, as it may impact future food choices, according to registered dietitian Joelle Malinowski. “In many circumstances, someone will choose that diet soda to decrease calories, but then replace those calories with a dessert after dinner,” she shared with The List. And that swap would negate any benefit that you’d get from eating Splenda in the first place. So, like with any food, your mileage may vary.